2023 - Thiago Zamprogno (Miami Herald), Logan Keothavy (Sun-Sentinel Broward)
2022 - Thiago Zamprogno (Sun-Sentinel Broward), Gino Briglio (Miami Herald), Zach Puentes (Sun-Sentinel Palm Beach)
2021 - Thiago Zamprogno (Miami Herald)
2020 - NO POY awarded due to COVID
2019 - Barrenger Ranck (Sun-Sentinel Palm Beach)
2018 - JT Martin (Miami Herald AND Sun-Sentinel Broward County), Ben Woody (Palm Beach Post)
2017 - JT Martin (Miami Herald AND Sun-Sentinel Broward County), Tervinson Lubin (Palm Beach Post), Ethan Fogt (Sun-Sentinel PB County)
2016 - Austin Reinhart (Palm Beach Post), Richie Diedrich (Orlando Sentinel)
2015 - Corry Short (Sun-Sentinel Broward County), Brockton Boretti (Sun-Sentinel PB County), Kevin Rocklein (Orlando Sentinel)
2014 - Andrew Washam (PB Post), Corry Short (Sun-Sentinel Broward County), Brockton Boretti (Sun-Sentinel PB County)
2013 - Jason Tellex (PB Post)
2012 - Tommy Tyson (PB Post AND Sun-Sentinel PB County), Yoel Benarroch (Sun-Sentinel Broward County)
2011 - David Specian (PB Post), David Frazee (Sun-Sent PB County), TJ Jurko (Sun-Sent Broward), Christian Francesci (Orange County)
2010 - David Specian (PB Post)
2009 - Andre Abadin (Miami Herald), Alex Pope (Sun-Sentinel)
2008 - Kyle Kurlander (PB Post)